(Serious Question) Naniniwala ba kayo na kasalanan ang pum@tay ng hayop at insekto?

[Malupetskii]

Nag-ooverthink lang po hahaha. Pero kidding aside, naniniwala ba kayo na kasalanan pumatay ng hayop at insekto? kung oo, bakit? kung hindi, bakit?

 

[Healer_Smile]

oks lang pumatay lalo na kung ipis at lamok ang usapan wala naman nakalagay sa bible na bawal pumatay ng ipis at lamok

 

[N E G A N]

May nag encourage ata sayo na vegetarian


Ano kakainin mo kung ayaw mo pumatay.

Ang hayup kabilang ang tao ay pumapatay in order to eat just saying.

Mapahalaman o hayup need mo patayin para makain mo.

Yung mga vegetarian na pakay nila kaya di sila kumain ng hayup kasi naawa sila pumatay ay isang hypocrisy.


In order to grow plants successfully ay need mo mag spray ng pesticide para patayin ang okay alam monayan.

2nd pumapatay rin sila ng halaman at di man lang sila naawa.

Parehas lang yan sila living things haha

 

[Asherah Goddess]

Depende sa conscience. Kapag feeling guilty, mag vegetarian ka na lang tutal mas healthy kaya kapag puros vegetables ang kinakain. Kaysa naman na puros karne but siyempre, balance pa rin pero kung hindi naman guilty, okay lang na kumain ng karne.

Tayo tao ay kaya lang naman tayo nagkakasala because of guilt so yung guilt is a sin. Yung mga buddhist monk , mga vegetarian ang mga iyan and nasa paniniwala nila na bawal talaga pumatay ng tao at hayop so ang kinakain nila ay mga gulay lang. They will feel guilty kapag kumain sila ng manok , hindi kaya sa conscience nila dahil nga bawal nga para sa kanila na pumatay na any living things po.

So follow your conscience.​

 

[PHC_LaCe12]

wala po sa bible ang ganyan kung bible ang basehan baka pro vegetarian nag usap ng ganyan sa yo

yung na usap na vegetarian sa yo try ask it kung anong stand nya sa hayop na kumain ng kapwang hayop inshort carnivores

 

[HowSoonIsNow]

nasa bible man o wala yan, depende sa dahilan mo kung baket mo papatayin yung bagay na may buhay. kung trip trip mo lang at senseless ang gagawin mo, aba eh pa check up ka sa psychologist baka lumala yan at sa susunod hindi n lang insekto o hayop ang gusto mong patayin. if necessary for example, kelangan mong kainin yung hayop para mabuhay, walang masama doon. kung sa insekto nman, kung perwisyo sayo, ok lang din. sa totoo lang wala namang aksyon na matatawag na kasalanan eh. religion mo lang ang nagsasabi na kasalanan ang isang aksyon na hindi naaakma sa gawain nila. ang meron lang is right and wrong based on our own consience.

 

[OrangeMoon]

Sagot ni GPT

The question of whether it is a sin to kill animals or plants touches on ethical, religious, and philosophical considerations. Different cultures, religions, and philosophical systems offer varied perspectives on this issue. Let’s explore some of these perspectives to provide a well-rounded view:

1. Religious Perspectives:
   • Christianity: Traditional Christian doctrine does not consider killing plants to be sinful, as they are seen as part of the natural resources provided by God for human use. The killing of animals is not inherently considered a sin, particularly when done for food, clothing, or other necessary purposes. However, cruelty to animals or wasteful killing without purpose is generally condemned.
   • Hinduism: Many Hindus practice ahimsa, or non-violence, which includes minimizing harm to all living beings, including animals and sometimes even plants. Vegetarianism is common among Hindus due to this principle, although practices vary widely.
   • Buddhism: Similar to Hinduism, Buddhism places a strong emphasis on non-violence and compassion for all living beings. Many Buddhists are vegetarian or vegan and strive to avoid killing animals. The treatment of plants is generally less of a concern, though the unnecessary destruction of life, including plant life, is discouraged.
   • Islam: In Islam, animals can be killed for food through a specific method known as halal, which is designed to minimize suffering. Killing animals unnecessarily or cruelly is considered sinful. Plants are regarded as a blessing from Allah for human sustenance and are not generally considered in the same ethical realm as animals.
2. Philosophical Perspectives:
   • Utilitarianism: This ethical theory suggests that the right action is the one that maximizes overall happiness or well-being. Killing animals or plants might be justified if it leads to a greater good, but unnecessary harm or cruelty would be seen as wrong.
   • Deep Ecology: This philosophy recognizes the intrinsic value of all living beings, not just humans. Adherents of deep ecology might argue against killing animals or plants unless absolutely necessary for survival.
3. Legal and Societal Norms:
   • In most societies, killing animals for food is legally and socially accepted, provided it is done within the framework of the law (e.g., hunting regulations, animal welfare laws).
   • Plants are generally not accorded the same moral or legal status as animals, and killing or harvesting plants for food, materials, or other purposes is widely accepted.
4. Personal Ethics:
   • Individuals may have their own ethical beliefs about the treatment of animals and plants, often influenced by their values, upbringing, and personal experiences.

In conclusion, whether it is considered a sin to kill animals or plants largely depends on one’s religious beliefs, philosophical viewpoints, and personal ethics. It’s important to approach such questions with an understanding of the diverse beliefs and practices that exist and to respect the convictions of others even if they differ from one’s own.

 

[Kaplok Kaplok]

Para masabi mong kasalanan ang isang bagay, maraming iba ibang standards kang kailangan pagbasehan.

Kung base sa religion, obviously, may kanya-kanya silang paliwanag. Kahit kung strictly philosophical and secular thinking may iba-iba din.

Ang mahahalagang tanong:

• How do you want to live your life?
• Do you want it to be based in logic or based in belief?
• Does truth matter with how you want to live your life? Or is your how you feel enough basis?

Sabi nga ng isang ni Socrates