To determine the limits on the design parameter K for stability, we need to analyze the roots of the characteristic equation.
The characteristic equation is given as:
s^4 + 3s^3 + 3s^2 + 2s + K = 0
For stability, all the roots of the characteristic equation must have negative real parts. This is known as the Routh-Hurwitz stability criterion.
To apply the Routh-Hurwitz criterion, we need to create the Routh array. Let's do that:
Coefficients of the characteristic equation:
a = 1, b = 3, c = 3, d = 2, e = K
Routh array:
Row 1: 1 3
Row 2: 3 2
Row 3: (6K - 9)/3 K
Now, let's analyze the signs of the elements in the first column of the Routh array.
For stability, all the elements in the first column must be positive.
i. 14/9 > K > 0:
Substituting K = 14/9, we get (6(14/9) - 9)/3 = (84/9 - 9)/3 = (84 - 81)/3 = 3/3 = 1, which is positive.
Substituting K = 0, we get (6(0) - 9)/3 = -9/3 = -3, which is negative.
Therefore, for 14/9 > K > 0, the first column of the Routh array has elements with alternating signs, which indicates the presence of poles with non-negative real parts. Hence, this range of K does not guarantee stability.
ii. 14 > K > 0:
Substituting K = 14, we get (6(14) - 9)/3 = (84 - 9)/3 = 75/3 = 25, which is positive.
Substituting K = 0, we get (6(0) - 9)/3 = -9/3 = -3, which is negative.
Therefore, for 14 > K > 0, the first column of the Routh array has elements with alternating signs, which again indicates the presence of poles with non-negative real parts. Hence, this range of K also does not guarantee stability.
iii. 9/14 > K > 0:
Substituting K = 9/14, we get (6(9/14) - 9)/3 = (54/14 - 9)/3 = (27/7 - 9)/3 = (27 - 63)/21 = -36/21 = -12/7, which is negative.
Substituting K = 0, we get (6(0) - 9)/3 = -9/3 = -3, which is negative.
Therefore, for 9/14 > K > 0, the first column of the Routh array has all negative elements. This indicates that all the roots have negative real parts, ensuring stability.
iv. 9 > K > 0:
Substituting K = 9, we get (6(9) - 9)/3 = (54 - 9)/3 = 45/3 = 15, which is positive.
Substituting K = 0, we get (6(0) - 9)/3 = -9/3 = -3, which is negative.
Therefore, for 9 > K > 0, the first column of the Routh array has all positive elements. This indicates that all the roots have negative real parts, ensuring stability.
Based on the analysis, the correct answer is iv. 9 > K > 0.