Closed Thread Creation in PHC, Overlapping Topics? Where Do I Post?

[RxSniper007]

images for humor :)


so ginawa kong topic na ito dahil...
1. kailangan kong gumawa ng thread para mabalik ang pagka establish ko
2. na realize ko na kailangan ko din pala talaga malaman ang sagot dito sa tanong na ito dahil ayoko naman lumalabag sa rules
3. gusto ko din gumawa ng useful topics minsan. di lang ako sure kung saan



Disclaimer: I know that users are subject to following rules of any websites that users want to use their service,
so as I have read from other peoples comments here about the new PHC rules like to maintain ESTABLISHED status you have to create a Thread every 30 days,
I think that is to make this community active in creating and sharing useful things together.
we just can't be leechers forever lols so I think this rule is meant for us to give back to the community.

(and also some other thoughts and reasons i have about this but i'll keep them to myself)

Spoiler: I Also Hate Politics Tho and 9/10 Would Avoid LOL :)

Spoiler contents are visible only to Established Members.

========================================
SO.... Back to the topic. haha
yung aking question ay, kung may mga overlapping na mga topic san forum dapat ito ilagay?

I've read the rules... Tutorial PHCorner Forum Rules
ang gusto ko malaman yung opinion ng ibang PHC members dito...

example lang ah parang yung game na "sum'mer'time saga" if you know it. it crosses all this topics:
PC game, Android game, and also Ad'ult content.
so san sya ilalagay?
anyway di lang limited yung tanong ko sa ganitong klaseng example ah?
it covers any crossing topics.

what are your opinions mga ka-PHC

 

[Grimzynk]

Depende kasi 'to sa type of thread topics you're going to make. Like for example:
Someone's asking about his/her concerns: "Pumutok CP ko, paano ko 'to papasabugin" "Nasira 'yung keypads ng Tablet ko, paano ko 'to papaltan ng keyboard" "Ayaw mag-play ng jpeg at png sa phone ko". 'Yung mga ganung concerns ba. Ahem! Siguro nga may existing thread na may kaparehong topic, pero ang problema outdated na 'yung thread(2018 pa 'yung last reply dun, 2020 na ngayun). Baka 'pag nag-reply ka dun tungkol sa concerns mo, it might be considered as thread hijacking or necroposting. Well, kung allowed naman dito 'yun, then wla ng problema siguro. Then what about sa ibang sections like: games, e-books, media, nsfw...

Ok let's talk about tutorial threads: There's someone who wants to share her/his tutorial about something, pero meron ng existing thread about similar topic. Then hindi nya na lang itutuloy. But, there's always an "if".
"What if that tutorial was already out of date?" "What if there are some differences between their tutorials?"

About games, e-books, media: Madali lang yan kasi may "original titles" karamihan jan(kaya easy search lang via quick search tool). Mas maganda sana kung may Index ng mga laman ng section na 'yun(pero kelangan ng mod jan o masipag ng volunteer user).

Kung mas popular 'yung thread mas maraming pages yan, so kung dun mo i-sha-share 'yung update mo madali lang din matatabunan unless alam 'nung ibang user ang specific page ng post mo, kinakailangan pang mag-backread nung iba para lng makita nila. Pwede mo rin naman i-ask 'yung OP ng thread na isama nya na lng 'yung link(s)/updates mo sa first post. However, what if the thread was over 2 months old na(kahit ikaw 'yung mismong OP, problema mo rin 'to) or in-active na 'yung OP or non-stab si OP.

Mukhang di ko nasagot 'yung concerns mo ah, haha, I'd just voiced out my own concerns. Hmm.. voice out ba tamang term jan?