What's new

Smart People can have Bad ideas

Kaplok Kaplok

Forum Guru
Elite
Joined
Oct 19, 2020
Posts
2,971
Reaction
1,283
Points
2,030
When we hear bad ideas from people, we typically assume that they are stupid. Or perhaps we put them in an box in our mind labeled as "bad people". But let us talk about that, and how that shouldn't be the case.

EINSTEIN'S BLUNDER
During Einstein's work on general relativity, through his calculation he already found that the universe is unstable. Versus the known idea in that time, which describes the universe as static and constant. He thought this was problematic, so he tweaked his calculations to fit a static and constant universe. This remained a belief until Hubble observed signs that the universe is expanding. Einstein regarded this as his greatest blunder.
3888.jpg

Even Einstein, a smart man, fell prey to the human tendency to hold certain ideas as sacrosanct. We can assume that most of us is not as smart as Einstein, so we are all vulnerable to holding bad ideas, very specially once we put some of them to a status of high value.

NO ONE LIKES BAD IDEAS
Contrary to our misunderstanding against them, people who believe in bad ideas do not like believing in "bad ideas". They truly believe that the ideas are good. If it was just possible to fully understand their perspective, it is the opposite idea that is bad for them.

That is what's dangerous about bad ideas. It does not reveal its identity. Even to a point that these ideas are used to perform atrocities to our fellow human, the holder of the idea can still justify it. And this is not only a "them" problem, as this includes all of us.

Here is something to ponder on. Not everyone is gifted equally in argumentative capability. Imagine a not-so-smart person with a good idea debating with a smart one with a bad idea. Do you think you will be capable enough to side with the good idea or will you be more inclined to believe the good argument?
Feature-1-1.png


WHICH TO CRITICIZE

We are in an age of communication. Through this connectedness, we can easily acquire both good and bad ideas. And it is also equally accessible to find criticsms against them. Comment sections and forums has provided us a means to put the ideas out there to be subjected to scrutiny. But which ideas should we criticize? Commonly we criticize the "bad" ideas, because that is what seems intuitive. But what is the point doing that? If it was already assigned as "bad", you probably don't hold the idea. Ideally, we should be criticizing the "good" ideas. Simply because these are what we hold, and these are the ideas that contains beliefs that we ourselves hold sacrosanct. And just like Einstein, these are the ideas that will be capable of misleading us - and the only way out is accepting that we may be wrong, by humbling ourselves to a different idea.

Otherwise, we will be stuck in echo chambers that affirms our belief over and over again, to a point that it becomes our second nature.
file-20190903-175700-1h9ic1n.jpg

This is how smart people can have bad ideas. Doesn't even matter how smart you thought you were. We have to stop and think: Are We In Control of our Thoughts?


Thank you for reading.
 

Attachments

Last edited:
Thanks for posting this kind of productive article. At least it brings a little awareness about ourselves.
 
wow thanks for confirming that every person can always set which things are bad for them and change accordingly, i am one of those people holding things which are bad to any other people and i classify these things as good
 
Edited: linked to related content

wow thanks for confirming that every person can always set which things are bad for them and change accordingly, i am one of those people holding things which are bad to any other people and i classify these things as good
Good for you.
Just a word of advice, it is more important to be aware of your belief than others. If you decide your position based on others' opinion, regardless of your agreement or not, you are nothing but a shadow of their opinion.
 
Last edited:
Edited: linked to related content


Good for you.
Just a word of advice, it is more important to be aware of your belief than others. If you decide your position based on others' opinion, regardless of your agreement or not, you are nothing but a shadow of their opinion.
good sa akin yung bad sa inyo is basing on others pala? hehe
 
This is a good read. I just recalled the time I'm atheistic that I bought almost all good arguments against the biblical stance in our culture without even understanding its role on how we govern ourselves. Pascal's wager is worth a try, I guess? :)

It is more important to be aware of your belief than others. If you decide your position based on others' opinion, regardless of your agreement or not, you are nothing but a shadow of their opinion.

I think that is how ideological possession is manifesting in one's mind. Leveraging your stance by uttering the ideas of the group. A reminder we all should be aware of.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top