Closed About Requirements On React First And Reply New Feature

[Reverser]

Hello Administration,

Dun sa recently feature na naimplement nyo po, which requires users to reply and give reaction first bago makita content.
I notice na madaming nagsspam comments like

" ty "
" psilip "
" nc "
" silip "
" try "

and blah blah.

They wont even care to re-comment or edit their previous comment to give a feedback.

Its just di ko alam pano sabihin to, uneffective way of making phc a better forum?

Welp, my suggestion is to remove that feature to all users, and itira lang yung kahit reaction nalang ng user ok na.

In that way, mas magkakaroon ng trasparent feedback ang mga topics and TRENDING topics will be much of higher quality kasi instead of spammed comments which are made by users
na gusto makita yung content,
real and unforced feedbacks yung andun sa topic.


This is just my mere thoughts and feedback, no hate.

 

[ravage]

Good thoughts, pero my thoughts.... ganyan din naman ang ginagawa nila kahit wala yang feature na yan.
Anyway... it's all up to boss Draft .

 

[Tilamsik]

abuso yung reply first

 

[ravage]

abuso yung reply first

same din lang boss, dahil kung leecher lang talaga ang member at hindi naman true blue na phcitizen tapos aktong mamumulot lang kaya pupunta rito, pag nawala na ang pagka-estab at magpapa-estab lang ulit para makapamulot then ganyan din ang gagawin ng mga yan... patry, tnx, ty, nc... pati naman yung thank you or nice eh hindi pa mabuo man lang. Dadaanin lang sa tnx, ty or nc.
Kaasar lang ang peg ano? Di mo alam kung talagang tamad lang mag type or talagang nang-aasar.

 

[Zyzz]

Same thought

 

[Reverser]

Good thoughts, pero my thoughts.... ganyan din naman ang ginagawa nila kahit wala yang feature na yan.
Anyway... it's all up to boss Draft .

I think lumala sir, for instance.
May topic na 11-pager na pero kung sisilipin mo, puro " pa try, patingin ".
Siguro may dalawang feedback comments and the rest na is result nung " reply first ".

Unlike before its implemented minimal lang yung amount to leechers comment " patatak ",
And usually on first page noticable na yung amount ng feedbacks noon.
Hahaha

Not much of a difference. But a difference is a difference I guess.

 

[jackspedicey]

Totally agree on this one. Just my own opinion lang po, yung reply section is for feedbacks and questions. Since nakahide yung content kasi require pa ng "reply" eh ano ang mairereply namin since dipa namin natry yung shinare mo. Kaya karamihan nag cocomment ng anything random para lang maview yung content.

 

[Zyzz]

same din lang boss, dahil kung leecher lang talaga ang member at hindi naman true blue na phcitizen tapos aktong mamumulot lang kaya pupunto rito, pag nawala na ang pagka-estab at magpapa-estab lang ulit para makapamulot then ganyan din ang gagawin ng mga yan... patry, tnx, ty, nc... pati naman yung thank you or nice eh hindi pa mabuo man lang. Dadaanin lang sa tnx, ty or nc.
Kaasar lang ang peg ano? Di mo alam kung talagang tamad lang mag type or talagang nang-aasar.

Yung iba gagawa ng thread para magpa establish tapos may content na "Pa Estab" then may special mention sa admin, halatang hindi nagbabasa ng rules eh.

 

[ravage]

Totally agree on this one. Just my own opinion lang po, yung reply section is for feedbacks and questions. Since nakahide yung content kasi require pa ng "reply" eh ano ang mairereply namin since dipa namin natry yung shinare mo. Kaya karamihan nag cocomment ng anything random para lang maview yung content.View attachment 703962

Wait na lang natin desisyon ni boss.

Yung iba gagawa ng thread para magpa establish tapos may content na "Pa Estab" then may special mention sa admin, halatang hindi nagbabasa ng rules eh.

nakuh, mainit din si boss sa ganyan, binaban nya pag ganyan

 

[Zyzz]

Totally agree on this one. Just my own opinion lang po, yung reply section is for feedbacks and questions. Since nakahide yung content kasi require pa ng "reply" eh ano ang mairereply namin since dipa namin natry yung shinare mo. Kaya karamihan nag cocomment ng anything random para lang maview yung content.View attachment 703962

Napunto mo paps, ganyan talaga kalalabasan niyan kaya ang lalabas niyan update post or double post kung talagang mag bibigay ng real feedback.

 

[iamBARTX]

Totally agree on this one. Just my own opinion lang po, yung reply section is for feedbacks and questions. Since nakahide yung content kasi require pa ng "reply" eh ano ang mairereply namin since dipa namin natry yung shinare mo. Kaya karamihan nag cocomment ng anything random para lang maview yung content.View attachment 703962

i think ang may mali is yung gumawa ng thread mismo. kasi di naman ganyan ang irereply nila kung andun na lahat ng info sa thread. dapat kasi ang naka hide lang dapat is yung mismong link of apps/config na sinishare.

yung iba kasi buong thread nakahide yun ang mali.

 

[Reverser]

i think ang may mali is yung gumawa ng thread mismo. kasi di naman ganyan ang irereply nila kung andun na lahat ng info sa thread. dapat kasi ang naka hide lang dapat is yung mismong link of apps/config na sinishare.

yung iba kasi buong thread nakahide yun ang mali.

You are right sir. For instance pang rooted lang pala yung topic ni ts pero dahil naka hide yung info na yun.
Mapapacomment nun 80% nonrooted users.

Which means useless comments = spam comments.

 

[iamBARTX]

You are right sir. For instance pang rooted lang pala yung topic ni ts pero dahil naka hide yung info na yun.
Mapapacomment nun 80% nonrooted users.

Which means useless comments =spam comments.

alam ko ang purpose lang hide features is para maprevent yung mga hit and runners na simpleng thanks lang sa nagshare hindi nila magawa. yes sharing is caring, pero ano ba naman yung magpasalamat sila which is malaking bagay na sa nagshare.

 

[Draft]

Idaan ko nalang sa botohan.
https://phcorner.net/threads/776848/post-13563444

 

[zhaaai]

Uhm newbie lang po ako dito ang dami ko pong nakikitang ganyang feedback mostly leecher mag comment at mag react po sila ng 2-3 times a day yung mga leecher ang dali pong umangat. Kagaya kopo nung una pabasa pabasa lang po ako and then medyo nasarapan ako dito kaya naisipan ko narin pong mag post ng sarili kong thread. Pero ang punto kopo dun bago ako mag post ng thread nagulat ako biglang naging GRASSHOPPER napo agad ako. Iniisip kopo baka dahil sa comment and reacts kopo yun kaya umangat ako ng grasshopper galing leecher. Aminado po na bakit parang ambilis ko pong umangat parang unfair naman po sa iba na superactive tapos veterans napo. Sensya kung pakielamero po ako hehe yun lang po saken mga lods

 

[ravage]

Aminado po na bakit parang ambilis ko pong umangat parang unfair naman po sa iba na superactive tapos veterans napo. Sensya kung pakielamero po ako hehe yun lang po saken mga lods

So ano, gusto mo ibalik na lang kita sa grasshopper, grasshopper forever?

 

[zhaaai]

So ano, gusto mo ibalik na lang kita sa grasshopper, grasshopper forever?

depende boss hahaha if trip niyo po ako hahaha di seryodo boss mas marami pang comment ang leecher kesa sa mga estab hahaha spam napo masyado boss yung mga bagong thread na importante or makakatulong natatabunan po sayang naman hirap maghukay boss hahaha

 

[ravage]

depende boss hahaha if trip niyo po ako hahaha di seryodo boss mas marami pang comment ang leecher kesa sa mga estab hahaha spam napo masyado boss yung mga bagong thread na importante or makakatulong natatabunan po sayang naman hirap maghukay boss hahaha

We understand, at di rin naman namin ipinagbabawal yang mag rank-up kahit pa mga "thanks" lang or "pa-try", "pa-wards" or kung ano pa man yan. We aunderstand the fact na hindi naman talaga lahat ng members ay may capacity to share.
Basta paalala ko lang time and again, wag ipagmamalaki yang mga rank na yan sa mga bagong salta.

 

[zhaaai]

We understand, at di rin naman namin ipinagbabawal yang mag rank-up kahit pa mga "thanks" lang or "pa-try", "pa-wards" or kung ano pa man yan. We aunderstand the fact na hindi naman talaga lahat ng members ay may capacity to share.
Basta paalala ko lang time and again, wag ipagmamalaki yang mga rank na yan sa mga bagong salta.

okay po hindi naman po ako nag jujudge ng mga leecher nanggaling din naman lahat dun tsaka wala man sa rules or nasa rules yun alam naman po natin sa sarili natin yun attitude nalang po nakadepende naman po sa tao hehe

 

[Kentify]

you see this kind of feature has advantages and disadvantages.

Advantage:

• it avoids hit and run tactics.
• it is rewarding sa TS/OP kasi may reaction score syang matatanggap.
• it motivates the OP/TS to share more.
• it promotes interaction of the members by posting feedbacks/question.
• Gain Medal Badges faster.
• and etc...

Disadvantages:

• it is prone to spamming or trash comments like "pa try", "try", "patingin", "pa bm" and many more.
• it is prone to all smiley/smiley only comments which is against the PHC rules.
• it is also prone to abuses like hidereact a useless contents to gain/scam a user for reacting.
• it is also confuses the user especially to the leecher/new member who doen't know how it works.
• it is also promote spamming/double posting.
• and many more to mention.

In the end of the day, for me this feature is Good/Helpful BUT then again the TS/OP is still the main reason why the feature look bad and not helful kasi nga ina-abuso nila ung system which is sad